A Day in the Life… How Short-Term Power Traders Operate

Category
energy-trading
Written on
17 Oct 2022
Authored by
Alexander Reinhold, CEO
An overview of the differences between asset-backed and asset-less (proprietary) power traders and their routine workflows
No alternative text provided

Weather-based power markets, characterized by extreme volatility within short time horizons, require energy market participants to calibrate their trading strategies accordingly.

Therefore, both asset-backed and asset-less power traders continuously analyze market trends and patterns to derive trading decisions and execute orders in volatile short-term power markets.

Let’s explore the key differences between asset-backed and asset-less traders and learn what their typical workflows look like.

Asset-Backed Traders vs. Asset-Less Traders

Asset-backed traders (renewable assets in particular) are dependent on power production forecasts and production actuals when making volume decisions. They usually submit forecasted volumes in the Day-Ahead auction and use Intraday markets to correct forecast deviations. 

In this way, whenever asset-backed traders end up producing less/more power than they sold in the Day-Ahead auction, most European regulators       require them to balance out their position by buying/selling the outstanding volumes in Intraday markets.

Let’s suppose one sold 15 MWh in the Day-Ahead auction for the 10-11 product. However, according to the latest forecast, actual production will equal 12 MWh during that hour. Accordingly, 3 MWh shall be bought in Intraday markets before gate closure.

In turn, asset-less power traders (often referred to as proprietary or simply prop traders), buy and sell arbitrary volumes of power provided that their balance is equal to zero at gate closure.

Compared to asset-backed traders, asset-less traders can open a speculative position in the Day-Ahead auction with the aim to close it in the Intraday markets against a positive spread (please note that some transmission system operators do not allow asset-less traders to participate in the Day-Ahead auction).

Let’s say a trading company buys 10 MWh in the Day-Ahead auction at 100 €/MWh (MCP) for the 10-11 product. Then, they sell 10 MWh in Intraday markets at an average of 105 €/MWh — with a 5 €/MWh spread — to get 50 € of profit. 

Let's zoom in on the typical workflows of both asset-backed and asset-less traders.

Short-Term Power Traders Workflows

Data processing is one of the three essential steps in the short-term power trading value chain       and a key to identifying spread opportunities in Day-Ahead and Intraday markets.

Both asset-backed and asset-less traders predominantly analyze the same technical and fundamental data, relying on some sort of data processing pipelines       and third-party data suppliers. Manual, computer-assisted and automated trading strategies are commonly exposed to the following data:

  • Virtual power plant (only relevant for asset-backed traders), depicting actual production and status of each solar and wind asset in a trader’s portfolio. 

  • Asset production forecasts (only relevant for asset-backed traders), indicating continuous volume forecasts of a trader’s production portfolio. Usually, traders aggregate insights from at least two forecast providers to increase their accuracy. 

  • Country-level solar/wind production and demand forecasts, commonly obtained from third-party data providers and ENTSO-E Transparency, an open-source energy data platform, managed by transmission system operators (TSOs). 

  • Raw weather data such as cloud covers, pressure, temperature, wind speeds, etc. 

  • Live order books, where all market orders are recorded. 

  • TSO publications, indicating the market balance. 

  • Urgent market messages (UMMs), announcing outages that may influence the price.

  • Power exchange websites/APIs (e.g. EPEX Spot, Nordpool) to obtain key indicators like traded volumes, market prices, etc. 

The majority of all short-term power trading decisions are still made by traders on the basis of visually inspecting the available data and applying trade rules. These decisions are usually translated into direct orders manually or communicated to a third-party trading application by means of simple parameters.

Verdict 

Most short-term power traders are still reliant on manual data analysis when deriving trading decisions that may allow for delayed reactions to data updates, intuition-based decision making and tedious order execution.

However, given advancements in computing power and data science, short-term power markets will inevitably move towards higher degrees of automation      , replacing manual data analysis and human decision making by fully automated trading engines with seamlessly integrated data processing pipelines and computer-assisted order execution.

More from the category

No alternative text provided
energy-trading
The Basics of Machine Learning Operations in Power Spot Trading

Discover how machine learning operations (MLOps) practices are applied in power spot trading to accelerate and facilitate the whole ML model lifecycle.

Sourabh Raj, Head of Data Science
10 Aug 2023
No alternative text provided
energy-trading
A Beginner’s Guide to the M7 Application Programming Interface

Learn more about the peculiarities of the M7 API and the mechanics of connecting a trading application to the EPEX Spot backend system

Gautam Kotian, Lead Software Engineer
24 Apr 2023
No alternative text provided
energy-trading
What’s What? Manual Trading vs. Computer-Assisted Trading vs. Automated Trading

Explore the three degrees of automation along the short-term power trading value chain — from manual approach to computer-assisted trading and end-to-end trading automation

Alexander Reinhold, CEO
28 Oct 2022
No alternative text provided
energy-trading
The Importance of Order Execution in Intraday Continuous

Thorough exploration of the peculiarities of continuous trading and the role of computer-assisted order execution strategies in Intraday power markets

Mario Nakhle, Product Management
27 Dec 2022
No alternative text provided
energy-trading
The Effect of Rising Prices and Volatility on Computer-Assisted Trading

Let’s shed light on the long-lasting effect that recent rise in power prices and volatility levels had on computer-assisted trading

Mario Nakhle, Product Management
7 Mar 2023
No alternative text provided
energy-trading
The Dynamics of Power Spot Prices: an Overview

A look into the nature of daily power prices that remain in constant flux under the influence of heterogeneous fundamental and technical drivers

Kamil Pluta, Systematic Trading
7 Dec 2022
No alternative text provided
energy-trading
Short-Term Power Trading: A Value Chain Perspective

From data processing to intelligence decision making to order execution — explore the life cycle of short-term power trades

Alexander Reinhold, CEO
19 Sept 2022
No alternative text provided
energy-trading
The Role of Transmission System Operators in Energy Trading

Let’s zoom in on the role of transmission system operators — the key market players responsible for the stable energy system operation and uninterrupted power transmission — and their effect on energy trading

Alexander Reinhold, CEO
17 Jan 2023
No alternative text provided
energy-trading
Power Trading: An Introduction

An overview of long- and short-term power trading — explore the differences between futures, over-the-counter and spot power markets and their complexities

Alexander Reinhold, CEO
15 Sept 2022
No alternative text provided
energy-trading
How to Derive Trading Decisions Systematically

A detailed look into the intricacies of creation and implementation of decision-making systems in power spot trading

Mario Nakhle, Product Management
16 Dec 2022
No alternative text provided
energy-trading
European Power Balancing Markets: an Overview

A deeper dive into the main instruments applied in balancing markets to counteract the deviations between supply and demand

Kamil Pluta, Systematic Trading
3 Feb 2023
No alternative text provided
energy-trading
Energy Mix in the Age of Renewables: An Overview

A quick refresher on the basic energy concepts and peculiarities of renewable energy sources

Alexander Reinhold, CEO
13 Sept 2022
No alternative text provided
energy-trading
A Look into Data Processing in Short-Term Power Trading

An in-depth look at the six crucial stages of data processing commonly applied across the power industry to facilitate data-driven decision making

Mario Nakhle, Product Management
15 Nov 2022
No alternative text provided
energy-trading
A Deep Dive into Cross-Border Transmission Capacities Allocation

Learn how cross-border transmission capacities — that allow to transfer power across a border — are allocated in futures and spot markets

Kamil Pluta, Systematic Trading
28 Feb 2023